Job costing spreadsheet or software?
Last checked 7 November 2026
A good spreadsheet is a fine way to cost a job. Our trade list came from a real NSW builder's sheet. Here's when one is enough, when it stops being enough, and what moving off it really takes. We sell the alternative, so weigh this accordingly.
A spreadsheet is enough when
- You run a job or two at a time, and they're straightforward.
- One person keeps the file, and everyone else asks that person.
- You know your formulas, and you check them.
- You know which copy is the real one.
- You want it free, and you want it to work with no signal.
If that's you, keep it. Nothing here is worth paying for just to feel organised.
It stops being enough when
- More than one person is updating it. The office has one copy, the site has another, and someone is working from last week's.
- A dragged cell breaks a total. Nothing tells you. You find out when a number stops making sense, if you find out.
- Variations and claims sit apart from the estimate. A variation on one tab only changes the profit on another if someone wired it up and nobody has broken it since.
- Profit is a handover surprise. By the time the sheet is tidied up and right, the money is spent.
- Someone asks who changed a figure. A shared file keeps some edit history if it's stored online, and it's there if you go looking. A copy on a laptop keeps none.
Side by side
| Compared on | Your spreadsheet | Buildtimate |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free, or part of your Microsoft or Google plan | $3 or less per job, per month + GST |
| Estimate against actual | If your formulas hold | On every line. Actual comes from the payments you record, and can't be typed over |
| Profit | Whatever the total cell says | One number per job, and one across all your jobs |
| Variations | A row or a tab you add | Logged against the original estimate |
| Claims and payments | A tab, if you keep one | Each with a due date, and anything overdue gets flagged |
| Documents | A folder somewhere else | With the job |
| History | Some, if it's stored online | Every change, with who and when |
| More than one person | Emailed copies, or one shared file | Everyone on the same numbers, up to your plan's user limit |
| Layout | Anything you like | Three ledgers, with your own categories |
| No signal | Still works | Needs a connection |
| Getting your data out | It's your file | An Excel workbook, a data file and your documents, whenever you like |
| Quotes | Another sheet | From your estimates, printed or saved as a PDF |
| Scheduling | Another sheet, if you want one | Not in Buildtimate |
What moving off it really takes
- You bring your estimates across. Paste a job's rows from your sheet or pick its
.xlsxor.csv, and check every row before it's saved. It's one job at a time, and it's new, so your sheet may need tidying first. Start with your next job, not your whole book. - Your categories come with you. Use your own, or start from ours.
- Your books don't change. Buildtimate isn't accounting software. There's no Xero sync, so a payment gets typed into Buildtimate and into your books.
- You can run both. Keep the sheet going on your first job and check one against the other. 60 days, 5 jobs, 3 users and no card, so it costs nothing to find out.
- You can go back. Your spreadsheet is still there, and an admin can download everything as an Excel workbook first. If you stop, the workspace locks and is later deleted, and we email you before that happens.
Looking at other software too?
If you need takeoffs, online quote signing or scheduling, Buildtimate isn't it. See it next to Buildxact, Fergus and the others.
Start free trialNo card · 60 days · 5 jobs · 3 users